When I tell my friends and family that we use cloth diapers, the first reaction of many is “I couldn’t stand dealing with the dirty
diapers.” Too squeamish for cloth diapers? Well, let’s put it this way, parenting in general is not for the squeamish!
Anyone dealing with infants and toddlers is changing diapers. You’ll be wiping buns and will be seeing, smelling and dealing with poo whether you are using cloth or disposable. Many parents who use disposable diapers just wrap up the poo and throw it in the trash. Using cloth involves one extra small step: I take the solid waste and flush it down the toilet–this involves either a gentle shake or a bit of toilet paper to help it off. It’s no worse than wiping it off of my child’s behind. I then fold up the diaper and toss it into my wet bag which I then cinch shut with its drawstring. And I’ve only been doing this since my son started eating solid foods. When he was a newborn, I tossed his soiled diapers directly into the wet bag without even wiping them off. There was no need.
Others worry that the diaper pail will smell. And to this I say, “Yes, it will.” Of course it will but NOT anymore than a garbage can full of soiled disposables–and since I toss most of the solid waste into the toilet, possibly less. If I do start to smell the diapers, then I know it’s time to do a load of laundry. I never let them sit for more than three days before I wash them which is probably another reason the smell is not a problem.
I think those parents who think they will be “grossed out” by the dirty cloth diapers they’ll need to wash are forgetting all of the other things they’ll be dealing with on a regular basis as parents: runny noses, hacking coughs, throw-up and bleeding boo-boos. Buck-up, I say! Cloth diapers involve hardly more interaction with “Poo” than disposables. For me, washing them involves emptying the wet bag directly into the washing machine, adding the detergent and turning on the machine. It’s not like most of us are washing them by hand these days so I’m not elbow-deep in dirty water.
If you are feeling open to using cloth but still haven’t made up your mind, the best thing you can do is to buy a few and try them out. It’s easier than most people think and using cloth is better for baby, the earth and saves money too–and nobody can say they feel squeamish about that!

I used cloth diapers on my babies from 2002 to 2009 but used disposables while traveling or a few other times when life got stressful. (My last baby only wore disposables on one vacation. My second had health issues and used disposables a lot, comparatively.)
I found disposables STINKIER than cloth, including BEFORE they are used.
It’s definitely easier to deal with diapers as laundry than as trash.
There is no extra step required for cloth diapers. If you read the instructions on the package of disposables, you are also supposed to empty the diaper into the toilet before throwing the diaper in the garbage. I realize most people don’t do this, however, there are bilaws in most cities prohibiting this practice. Poop, from an animal or human, belongs in the sewer or the compost and not in a land fill. Diaper sprayers and rubber gloves are great tools to help reduce handling of solid waste.
Everyone always assumes I’m talking about prefolds, pins, and plastic pants when I talk about cloth diapers. I showed my uncle a pocket diaper at a Christmas gathering and he was shocked.
I heard a lot of “you’ll have some diapers that are so gross you just want to throw them away.” I have had some pretty rank diapers…but none that I wanted to throw out!
A lot of my family thinks it’s great that I’m doing cloth diapers, but they feel like they could never do it themselves….
Being a nursing student you come across things that are a lot more “squeam” provoking then baby poo. (Yay! I just made up a word) You are exactly right that being a parent in general means that you are going to deal with things that tickle your gag reflex, but that is part of being a parent and cloth diapers ARE really no worse then disposables!
People definitely looked at me like I was a crazy person when I told them I would be cloth diapering, but it’s been so much easier than I expected. Those disposable people don’t know what they’re missing–no giant smelly piles of trash to deal with, rarely a “blowout”, and oh so much cheaper.
This is the first thing my mom said to me when I told her I had decided to cloth diaper. Her idea of cloth diapers was so dated, that when we went shopping she was just shocked! She has watched me do laundry and is very jealous of how easy it is. Now I’m trying to convince me niece to do it too!
Liners reduce the “ick” factor even more. I really don’t understand when people tell me it’s really gross to cloth diaper. Potty training isn’t any less “gross” and I certainly don’t throw away clothes that get waste on them, they go in the machine to be washed. I fail to see the difference…
I actually laugh about this – because the 3 times DD has been in a disposable, we’ve had blowouts and needed a clothing change! Yuck. Poo in diaper = expected. Poo all up DD’s back, all over her clothes, all over my clothes – when we’re out (we thought a ‘sposie would be easier at the state fair…) = NOT expected and a heck of a lot more work than cloth diapers!
You really do get used to it. I’ve had to hand prewash a few (no diaper sprayer). Granted, I’m not particularly squeamish. Just think of all the long term good you’re doing (and money you’re saving). Cloth is worth it!!
Cloth diapers are much more reliable than I was expecting. When we first started using them I expected constant blow outs, but to my pleasure I have only had one (which was mostly my fault since I didn’t completely get the leg gussets around the cloth diaper). I don’t think I’ll ever stop using cloth.
We are expecting our first little one this summer and are very excited to use cloth diapers. Even my husband is on board with it! Your website has been very helpful with preparing us for this part of our new adventure!
Love thirsties!
I actually find my cloth MUCH LESS stinky than disposables. Disposables smell chemically before, during, & after use! After a few days in a diaper pail the stench was overwhelming, especially when I was pregnant! My cloth diapers just smell like cloth, and in the pail they don’t even stink much at all. I rinse all of mine before they go in the pail & wash every 2 days…I’ll take that over walking a disposable out to the trash every two hours in rain all spring, freezing temps in winter, 100+ degrees in the summer, etc!
I’ve been using disposables while Ih restock my stash…we’ve has some horrible blow outs that never happened with cloth. I would rather deal with a well contained mess than have to change bedding just because of a poo. Also, I’ve been using a cloth diaper pail lined with trash bags for the disposable, it stinks horribly! No where near the smell when it was holding our cloth dipes. I’m so glad I’ve got my stash nearly rebuilt!
Amen! I love the picture though! Too cute
I remember when my sister in law started using cloth… I thought she was crazy! However, when I actually saw how easy it was , and how much money she was saving, I was willing to give it a try. I am so glad I did, and I am so thankful that cloth diapers have evolved so much, that it really is easy!
Of course being a SAHM, I change most of the diapers, however, I just want to say that my husband has been so awesome about Cloth Diapers! He loves them! I have heard him telling friends at work how great and smart cloth diapers have been!
I’ve had much bigger, stinkier messes with disposables than
I’ve ever had with cloth! I’ll never go back to disposables!
I love my cloth diapers and not having to haul stinky loads to the dumpster. My bathroom always smells awful after I’ve changed a poopy disposable diaper. I think it probably helps a lot that most of that gets flushed when I use cloth. However, I take issue with, “This involves either a gentle shake or a bit of toilet paper to help it off.” Um, do you mean to say you’ve never had those diapers with reconstituted raisins that can only be cleaned with a blast from a fire hose? Poopy diapers that can be taken care of with a gentle shake are a rare and (relatively) pleasant event in this house. I don’t know what I’d do without my rubber gloves and diaper sprayer.
By submitting a comment you grant Thirsties Baby a perpetual license to reproduce your words and name/web site in attribution. Inappropriate and irrelevant comments will be removed at an admin’s discretion. Your email is used for verification purposes only, it will never be shared.